.png){kind=small}
Initial Draft Grades and Process
Below are my initial 2025 NFL Draft film-based grades and the top 25 player rankings in advance of the 2024 college football season. Each year, I start off by re-evaluating the prior year's grades for players who did not enter the previous draft. Then, I begin to add the additional underclassmen projected as potential high-end NFL Draft prospects. I grade these underclassmen and add them to the 50-60 players I had grades on from the prior year, starting with an initial top 25.
Grading Methodology
My grading process allows me to remain objective, which is important early in the process because there are many players whose TV copy or all 22 tapes I have yet to watch. With that said, using our proprietary multi-pronged process, I always like to keep my Big Board rankings "way too early" in order of the player grade. These grades can and will change for many prospects as they add additional film in 2024, but for now, this is what I have.
2025 Draft Class Evaluation
When evaluating the small sample size for the 2025 NFL Draft class, it is apparent that we are going to see a potential 180 flip from the 2024 offensively heavy NFL Draft, at least in the first round. The 2024 NFL Draft had zero defenders come off the board until Laiatu Latu at 15th overall, a first in NFL Draft history. If it were not for the need at the QB position in the NFL, the 2025 NFL Draft class could see as many as eight defenders off the board in the first ten picks with zero skill players off the board. That will not happen because of QB positional value and WR positional value, but there is a solid chance we see a 50-50 split in the top ten and a much heavier defensive draft on day one than we had in the 2024 NFL Draft.
Here is a breakdown by position group for the below top 25 rankings:
CB (Cornerback): 4
IDL (Interior Defensive Line): 4
ED (Edge Defender): 4
OT (Offensive Tackle): 3
WR (Wide Receiver): 3
QB (Quarterback): 3
S (Safety): 1
LB (Linebacker): 1
TE (Tight End): 1
RB (Running Back): 1
The Way Too Early 2025 NFL Draft Big Board Rankings
1). Travis Hunter, Colorado (CB, 6'1", 185 lbs)
Projection: Elite
Analysis: Travis Hunter stands out as a dynamic defensive talent, excelling as a shutdown cornerback with the versatility to also play safety. His combination of speed, athleticism, and physicality allows him to match up with any receiver, embodying a fearless approach. Drawing parallels to legends like Deion Sanders, Charles Woodson, and Devin Hester, Hunter mirrors their knack for playmaking. Overall, Hunter is a rare two-way talent with the potential to become a generational figure in the league.
2). Mason Graham, Michigan (IDL, 6'3", 318 lbs)
Projection: Elite
Analysis: Mason Graham primarily aligns as a 3-technique, showing versatility to position as a 1-technique, and occasionally plays outside the offensive tackle, with limited snaps in a more traditional defensive end or off-ball role. His strength at the point of attack and ability to disrupt both the pass and run game make him an ideal fit for defensive schemes that utilize defensive tackles in multiple roles, such as 4-3 systems where he can be a disruptive under-tackle, or in 3-4 systems as a versatile defensive end.
3). Will Johnson, Michigan (CB, 6'2", 205 lbs)
Projection: Elite
Analysis: A quintessential lockdown corner, Johnson can effectively erase half the field, granting defensive coordinators greater creativity with coverage schemes and blitzes. Will Johnson primarily aligns as an outside cornerback, with notable experience in the slot as well. His skill set and physical build make him an ideal fit for a team that employs a mix of man and zone coverages, where his length and agility can be best utilized.
4). James Pearce Jr., Tennessee (ED, 6'5", 245 lbs)
Projection: Near Elite
Analysis: James Pearce Jr. is an elite-level pass-rushing outside linebacker who excels not only in pressuring the quarterback but can also drop back into coverage. His physical traits and aggressive play style make him ideally suited for a 3-4 scheme as an outside linebacker, where he can leverage his speed and length to disrupt both passing and running plays.
5). Will Campbell, LSU (OT, 6'6", 325 lbs)
Projection: Near Elite
Analysis: Will Campbell has established himself as a premier left tackle, excelling in both pass protection and run blocking. His athleticism and technique allow him to effectively protect the quarterback's blind side and create lanes in the run game. He has shown versatility and consistency, making him an ideal fit for both zone and power running schemes due to his ability to engage and drive through defenders. His experience in a high-caliber collegiate program prepares him well for various offensive systems in the NFL.
6). Benjamin Morrison, Notre Dame (CB, 6'0", 185 lbs)
Projection: Near Elite
Analysis: Morrison thrives as an outside man/press cornerback, a role that capitalizes on his quick, short-area movements and ability to stay with receivers through routes. His physical style and agility make him ideal for teams looking for a cornerback who can handle top receivers one-on-one. Morrison's skills suggest he would fit best in defensive schemes that prioritize press and man coverage, where his ability to disrupt at the line of scrimmage and play physically downfield can be most effective.
7). Kenneth Grant, Michigan (IDL, 6'3", 340 lbs)
Projection: Near Elite
Analysis: Kenneth Grant has shown substantial growth in his ability to perform in various defensive alignments, indicating his adaptability and understanding of the game. Predominantly effective in the B gap, he demonstrates a profound impact against the run and in disrupting the pocket. His capabilities in the pass rush have increasingly been utilized, showcasing his versatility and potential adaptability to different NFL schemes. Grant would be particularly effective as a 3-technique in a 4-3 defense, leveraging his pass rush skills, or could serve well in a 3-4 scheme as a defensive end where his broad skill set can be utilized across the line.
8). Kelvin Banks, Texas (OT, 6'4", 324 lbs)
Projection: Near Elite
Analysis: Kelvin Banks Jr. exemplifies a modern offensive tackle with his light-footed agility and excellent balance. His play style suits a zone-blocking scheme particularly well, due to his ability to move laterally and engage moving targets in space. However, he has the raw attributes to adapt to a power scheme with further development in his strength and hand technique.
9). Deone Walker, Kentucky (IDL, 6'6", 348 lbs)
Projection: Near Elite
Analysis: Deone Walker is a versatile defensive lineman who can operate as a 1-tech nose tackle, a 3-tech IDL, or a 3-4 defensive end. His large frame, raw strength, and surprising agility are why he is rated so highly. Combining the attributes above with Walker's ability to occupy multiple blockers makes him a valuable asset in any defensive scheme at the NFL level.
10). Ashton Gillotte, Louisville (ED, 6'3", 270 lbs)
Projection: High-End Starter Potential
Analysis: Ashton Gillotte exhibits a dynamic blend of speed and power, making him a formidable force on the defensive line. His ability to generate quick pressure on quarterbacks through his explosive first step and bend around the edge is a critical asset. Gillotte's physical style and versatility make him an excellent fit in both 3-4 and 4-3 defensive alignments, as he has shown proficiency in playing across different positions on the line.
11). Luther Burden, Missouri (WR, 5'11", 208 lbs)
Projection: High-End Starter Potential
Analysis: Luther Burden III is a dynamic multi-role receiver who excels in a high-tempo, pass-oriented offense. His ability to perform after the catch and his nuanced route running make him a fit for both spread and West Coast offensive schemes. His physicality and competitive nature also make him valuable in situations where tough catches are required.
12). Malaki Starks, Georgia (S, 6'1", 205 lbs)
Projection: Near Elite
Analysis: Malaki Starks exhibits a balanced skill set that suits both man and zone coverage, making him versatile as a safety. His ability to read the quarterback and diagnose plays quickly is notable. Starks has shown effectiveness in slot/nickel situations, suggesting he could fit well in schemes that value multidimensional defensive backs who can cover, tackle, and play the ball. His experience and growing knowledge of defensive schemes, coupled with physical and mental development, indicate a strong adaptability to various defensive schemes at the NFL level.
13). Princely Umanmielen, Ole Miss (ED, 6'5", 255 lbs)
Projection: High-End Starter Potential
Analysis: Umanmielen's diverse skill set makes him suitable for both 3-4 and 4-3 defensive schemes. His ability to play with his hand in the dirt as a traditional defensive end in a 4-3 alignment, as well as his capability to stand up as an outside linebacker in a 3-4 front, highlights his versatility. Teams operating hybrid defenses would particularly benefit from his skill set, allowing them to utilize his strengths in multiple alignments depending on the game situation.
14). Tetairoa McMillan, Arizona (WR, 6'5", 210 lbs)
Projection: High-End Starter Potential
Analysis: Tetairoa McMillan primarily plays as an outside X-receiver, showcasing remarkable athleticism and a physical profile akin to NFL star Mike Evans. His playmaking ability and size make him an ideal fit for offenses that leverage deep threat receivers and require versatile play from the wide receiver position. His ability to create separation using his physicality and route precision complements vertical passing schemes well.
15). Harold Perkins, LSU (LB, 6'1", 250 lbs)
Projection: Near Elite
Analysis: Harold Perkins is a dynamic linebacker with a knack for being around the ball and making plays, particularly in the box. Despite his relatively smaller size for an edge rusher, his performance has not been hindered, as evidenced by his freshman season, where he tallied 7.5 sacks and continued to excel into his sophomore year with significant tackles for loss and sacks. He's shown adaptability in shifting from edge rushing to playing more centrally as an inside linebacker under LSU's scheme, which speaks to his versatility and potential fit in various defensive schemes at the professional level.
16). Shedeur Sanders, Colorado (QB, 6'2", 215 lbs)
Projection: High-End Starter Potential
Analysis: Shedeur Sanders is a mobile pocket passer with a remarkable ability to extend plays and improvise under pressure. He demonstrates consistent accuracy and timing on short to medium passes. Sanders has shown proficiency in navigating the pocket, using his athleticism effectively, and maintaining composure under pressure. However, his arm strength is considered average, and his footwork and overall throwing mechanics require refinement.
17). J.T. Tuimoloau, Ohio State (ED, 6'4", 270 lbs)
Projection: High-End Starter Potential
Analysis: In terms of scheme fit, Tuimoloau's combination of physical traits, pursuit abilities, and hand usage should allow him to fit well into multiple defensive schemes. While his primary role is likely to be as an edge rusher, his strengths against the run suggest that he could be used in a variety of ways depending on the defensive scheme and situation.
18). Emeka Egbuka, Ohio State (WR, 6'1", 205 lbs)
Projection: High-End Starter Potential
Analysis: Egbuka exhibits a play style that combines elite speed, agile route running, and the ability to make plays after the catch. His ability to perform both in the slot and on the outside makes him a versatile asset for any NFL team. Egbuka fits well in a spread offense that leverages his route-running skills and speed, making him a potent threat across all levels of the field.
19). Jonah Savaiinaea, Arizona (OT, 6'5", 330 lbs)
Projection: Mid-Level Starter Potential
Analysis: Jonah Savaiinaea is a massive offensive tackle who can also slot into an interior guard position if needed, showcasing versatility across the offensive line. His size and strength are his biggest assets, making him ideal for a power run scheme that leverages his ability to move defenders off the ball. His pass protection skills are advanced, particularly against bull rushes, but he must improve his agility and footwork to handle speed rushers at the NFL level. Savaiinaea's performance at Arizona has demonstrated significant potential for growth, especially in schemes that prioritize physical run blocking.
20). Carson Beck, Georgia (QB, 6'4", 220 lbs)
Projection: Mid-Level Starter Potential
Analysis: Carson Beck is a prototypical pocket passer with a poised and methodical approach to the game. He is most effective when given time to operate within the pocket, utilizing his strong arm and accuracy to execute the offense. Beck fits best in a pro-style offense that leverages his ability to make throws from the pocket and doesn't rely heavily on quarterback mobility. His play style is reminiscent of traditional drop-back passers, and he would excel in schemes that value precision passing and structured play designs.
21). Howard Cross III, Notre Dame (IDL, 6'0", 288 lbs)
Projection: High-End Starter Potential
Analysis: Howard Cross III is a powerful and stout interior defensive lineman, known for his ability to disrupt the run game. He has a solid build and uses his strength effectively to engage and shed blocks. While his pass rush skills are more limited, he shows potential in this area. Cross fits best in a 4-3 defensive scheme as a run-stopping DT, where his ability to plug gaps and control the line of scrimmage would be maximized.
22). Noah Fifita, Arizona (QB, 5'11", 196 lbs)
Projection: Mid-Level Starter Potential
Analysis: Noah Fifita is a quintessential pocket passer with a knack for precision and timing, making him a fit for pro-style or West Coast offenses that prioritize accuracy and decision-making over deep throws. His ability to read defenses and distribute the ball effectively makes him adaptable to various offensive schemes. Fifita is also an escape artist with good mobility. He can navigate the pocket to make a throw, keep a play alive to make throws outside of structure, or take off to pick up yards as a runner.
23). Tacario Davis, Arizona (CB, 6'4", 195 lbs)
Projection: Mid-Level Starter Potential
Analysis: Tacario Davis has flourished in a system that emphasizes heavy zone coverage, where his length and speed allow him to excel. Standing at 6-foot-4, he is a dominant physical presence on the field, capable of matching up against larger receivers.
24). Colston Loveland, Michigan (TE, 6'5", 245 lbs)
Projection: High-End Starter Potential
Analysis: Colston Loveland is a prototypical modern NFL tight end, effective as both a pass-catcher and a blocker. He thrives in an offense that utilizes the tight end as a key part of its passing game, similar to how Michigan has employed him. His ability to line up in multiple positions makes him a valuable asset for schemes that favor versatile tight ends who can create mismatches.
25). Donovan Edwards, Michigan (RB, 6'1", 210 lbs)
Projection: High-End Starter Potential
Analysis: Donovan Edwards is a talented running back, offering a great mix of speed, agility, and explosiveness. As a three-down back, Edwards brings valuable versatility to the field, where he can line up in the backfield, the slot, or split out wide as a receiver. Edwards's versatility could have allowed him to change positions from RB to WR a season ago, with Blake Corum gobbling up most of the backfield carries. He is exactly what NFL scouts and GM’s are looking for in today's NFL game at the RB position. Players like Donovan Edwards provide positionless versatility, and that's the direction in which the RB position appears to be trending.