2025 NFL Draft: Carl Smith, Robert Morris WR & Former Lafayette Team Captain A Potential Hidden Gem

Each year, the NFL Draft shines a spotlight on players whose journeys epitomize resilience, determination, and the ability to seize opportunities. Carl Smith, a wide receiver from Robert Morris University, is no exception. Known for his elite route-running ability, football IQ, and contagious competitive spirit, Smith is emerging as one of the most intriguing small-school prospects in the 2025 NFL Draft. With standout performances at the FCS Bowl and Tropical Bowl, Smith has caught the attention of scouts, solidifying himself as a player to watch.

High School and Recruiting Background

Hailing from Darby Township, Pennsylvania, Carl Smith excelled at West Philadelphia Catholic High School, where he earned All-Catholic League First-Team honors as a wide receiver and Second-Team honors as a defensive back. Known for his versatility, Smith recorded 40 receptions for 756 yards and 11 touchdowns in his senior year while contributing 68 tackles and seven interceptions on defense. His athletic pedigree is further emphasized by his sister Faith Ross, a three-time First Team All-American track star at the University of Kentucky, who was also an SEC Champion and NCAA Championship finalist.

Despite his impressive production, Smith was listed as a zero-star recruit by 247Sports. He committed to Virginia Tech as part of the Class of 2020 but transferred to Lafayette College after his freshman year. At Lafayette, Smith’s leadership blossomed, earning him team captaincy during the Leopards’ historic 2023 season, where they won their first Patriot League Championship and made their inaugural FCS playoff appearance.

College Football and Academic Background

Smith’s collegiate journey took him from Virginia Tech to Lafayette College, where he emerged as a team leader, and finally to Robert Morris University, where he showcased his polished skill set and earned attention from NFL scouts.

At Lafayette, Smith’s role steadily grew over three seasons (2021-2023). He played in 21 games, recording 12 catches for 145 yards and two touchdowns. Smith’s versatility was evident in his kick-return contributions, with seven attempts for 143 yards, averaging 20.4 yards per return.

As a senior in 2023, he served as team captain and led Lafayette to its first Patriot League Championship and FCS playoff appearance in school history. Despite a torn groin suffered in Week 3, Smith returned to inspire his team, highlighting his resilience and “We>Me” mindset.

In 2024, Smith transferred to Robert Morris University, where he excelled in the passing game. Over 10 games, he tallied 15 receptions for 277 yards and two touchdowns, averaging an impressive 18.5 yards per catch. He also demonstrated his ability in the run game, contributing 31 yards on one rushing attempt, further emphasizing his versatility.

FCS and Tropical Bowl Standout

Smith’s performances at the FCS Bowl and Tropical Bowl were pivotal in elevating his draft stock. His ability to consistently create separation, make contested catches, and showcase his football IQ drew praise from scouts and analysts. CBS Sports listed Smith as a standout performer in their coverage of both events, further solidifying his status as a draftable prospect.

At the Tropical Bowl, Smith’s ability to thrive in one-on-one matchups and his polished skill set were on full display. Scouts noted his smooth route running, quick releases, and ability to adjust to different coverage schemes. Smith himself commented on his performances, saying, “All I need is an opportunity… I’ll be sure to make the most of it.”

2025 NFL Draft Scouting Report

Strengths

• Route Running: Smith’s attention to detail in his routes sets him apart. He uses tempo, fast releases, and clean breaks to create separation, excelling in timing-based offenses.

• Football IQ: A student of the game, Smith’s understanding of defensive schemes and coverages is exceptional. His experience in a West Coast offense prepared him for NFL-level complexity.

• Versatility: Smith’s inside-outside flexibility allows him to thrive as both a slot and outside receiver. His willingness to block for the run game further demonstrates his unselfishness.

• Playmaking Ability: Quickness and craftiness after the catch make Smith a threat in open space, while his reliable hands allow him to secure difficult receptions.

• Competitiveness: Smith’s energy and “iron sharpens iron” mentality inspire teammates and elevate his play in critical moments.

  
  

Weaknesses

• Size Concerns: At 5’11” and 176 pounds, Smith may face challenges against larger NFL defensive backs. However, his technique and quickness help mitigate these disadvantages.

• Play Strength: While effective at the college level, adding functional strength will improve his ability to handle physical defenders and enhance his blocking.

  
  

NFL Style Comparison

• Jarvis Landry (New Orleans Saints): Smith’s game resembles (not a direct comparison) Landry’s in terms of route-running precision and his willingness to block in the run game.

NFL Draft Projection

• Projected Round: Undrafted Free Agent, Practice Squad, UFL Potential

• Best Scheme Fit: West Coast or Spread Offense, where his quickness and route-running can thrive in timing-based concepts.

Summary

Carl Smith is a highly competitive and polished wide receiver prospect whose technical expertise, versatility, and leadership qualities make him an ideal candidate for teams seeking a dependable receiver. Standing at 5’11” and 176 pounds, Smith compensates for his size with quickness, precise route running, and soft hands. His ability to impact the game as both a receiver and blocker showcases his team-first mentality, making him a valuable asset in multiple roles.

While projected as an undrafted free agent, Smith’s strong work ethic, football IQ, and passion for the game give him significant upside as a developmental player. Teams looking for a polished, high-character receiver with a chip on his shoulder would be wise to take a chance on this small-school standout.